FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
- General Questions
- Managing Computer Use
- Seeking Help & Counselling
Schools that require the student to buy a laptop would have some kind of structured program so that the laptop is fully utilized. More computer lessons can be conducted and it is hoped that the students learn more. However, I think the disadvantages of having a personal laptop under the school system outweigh the benefits.
First, let me share my personal experience before giving you the facts. When I had to choose a secondary school for my son, I had in mind a school that required the purchase of a personal laptop. If I had a choice, I would not have chosen this school because I do not agree that this is a good way to educate my child. There were other factors that I considered to be more important including distance to home and these were the factors that made me decide on the school.
The experience of my child has confirmed what I disliked. Having said this, I must say that I made a conscious decision in choosing this school knowing well what might happen. I live with the consequences of this choice. Do I regret choosing this school? I am not sure. Now for the disadvantages. Your child would be spending a lot of time learning some of the new technology but will not really master it. By the time your child leaves school, whatever he has learnt will be outdated. I think this is time wasted. There are some basic computer skills which he would be good at, for example doing research, using email and maybe creating his own videos but these are skills students from other schools would learn as well.
Laptops weigh about 2 kilos. It may seem light and the child is supposed to bring less books to school but believe me, if you have carried one of their bags, you will know it is heavy especially for a child.
Schools have rules in place to prevent the misuse and abuse of the computer. Most children would eventually use their laptops to play games even in school and teachers would not be in a position to stop this.
Children would also use their laptops to play games at home. The school would be right in saying that parents are responsible to supervise and guide their children but this is merely giving parents more work to do and will not stop the problem of children playing games. It is like having a field trip to the bar to educate children on the dangers of drinking alcohol. Such an environment is simply not appropriate for children.
Cigarettes carry warning labels on each pack but this has not deterred people from smoking. There are public education campaigns and gory ads but they too don’t seem to work. If these things don’t work, then why are we still doing it? I really don’t know but somehow it seems necessary. Yes, this may not seem like a good answer but it’s the best I can think of.
Elizabeth Wooley, a mother of a 21 year old gaming addict who shot himself once said, "Either you die, go insane or you quit. My son died." Actually the stats are in your favour. Less than one per cent will die (there may be one or two cases in Singapore so far), maybe 2 to 3 percent will go insane or give problems to society and the rest will eventually quit. Even for those who quit, they would probably have missed out a large part of their education and it is very difficult to get this back. The issue here also is, are you prepared for this and the other possible consequences?
If your fears are not addressed, nothing and no one can help you. This is because you will object to any plan that may be put forth to you because they will always be an element of uncertainty and risk which will raise your level of fear. Fear can prevent you from doing anything and you will not only feel helpless but believe that no one can help you come up with a solution.
After you have gone through personal or marital counselling, a plan of action needs to be discussed. Your counsellor should be able to discuss with you the alternatives available or you can find out more online. With the available information, you should make the decision together with your spouse (and some input from your counsellor) as to your next course of action.
In the early stages, an addict who is in denial would not see that he has a problem and would therefore refuse to go for counselling. Therefore, this is not a practical option for parents. In the later stages a child may be more willing to go for counselling. However, in my view counselling alone for the child will not resolve the issue. It will either not work or there may be a small improvement but this will not be lasting as relapse will set in very quickly. From what is known in other countries, some form of treatment is usually necessary and this treatment would inevitably involve some form of counselling. This means that the practical and long term solution would be to find a suitable treatment centre/program for your child.
In my view, it is necessary for parents to go for counselling (lasting several sessions at least). In most cases, there are personal or marital issues that need to be resolved first. This includes identifying the factors that contribute to codependency, unrealistic expectations and emotional stability of the parent. The marital issues that need to be addressed are the beliefs that each parent has, the conflicting methods that are used to deal with the problem and the breakdown of marital relationship that is affecting the child. In many cases you will find that one parent is very strict (usually father) and the other very lenient (usually mother).
Once the above has been resolved, counselling can go on to the next stage where the purpose would be to help parents in a decision making process. They both have to agree on some kind of intervention plan which is to eventually send their child for treatment or to manage the situation themselves using consequences that they can agree on.
The fact that your son is prepared to talk to a counsellor does not mean that your case is urgent. It is natural for you to feel anxious as you have been unsuccessfully trying to get him to seek help. It also does not mean that your son is ready for counselling. He may have agreed because he wanted to stop you from nagging at him or said it on impulse as he did not know what else to say since he did badly for his exams.
If you want to get him to see a counsellor immediately, you have to consider the risks involved. It is possible that your son is not ready for counselling and he may end up having a negative experience for the session. He may see it as a waste of time or that you have put him to shame for bringing up his habit to a counsellor. This will jeopardize your future efforts in getting him to seek treatment. If your son is ready for counselling, it is easier for change to take place and he would not be too antagonistic towards you.
Prior arrangements need to be made so that admission procedures will go smoothly. Now comes the tricky part as your son would not to go to the treatment centre. If you were in the United States, you could find a professional who could work with you on a method called an intervention to get your son to be admitted to the treatment centre. The reported success rate of this is around 80 - 90% but I am not aware of this being available in Singapore. Your options are basically to seek the advice of the treatment centre or speak to your counsellor. If you do not find this useful, I am afraid treatment in Singapore is not a practical option at this point.
All the different advice you get can confuse you. You would also probably have tried what has been suggested but it has not worked. When you get advice, there are a few things to consider.
- Have you given sufficient and relevant information to the person you talked to?
- What are the reasons and the thinking behind the method suggested?
- If it has been tried, what are the reasons behind your failure?
